Report: Most Search Marketers are Unsophisticated

The majority of search marketers are unsophisticated, despite having worked in the field for two or more years, according to a study by JupiterResearch.

A special report from the Search Engine Strategies conference, December 13-16, 2004, Chicago, IL.

Niki Scevak, an analyst at JupiterResearch, took a look at how marketers are using search, and emerging trends in search marketing. He also introduced Gary Stein, a senior analyst at JupiterResearch, who joined in the Q&A that followed Scevak’s presentation.

Based on its latest Survey of Search Marketer Behavior, JupiterResearch considers three quarters of search marketers currently using unsophisticated search engine marketing (SEM) tactics. “Only one in four search marketers bids and measures intelligently,” said Scevak.

To segment “sophisticates” and “unsophisticates,” JupiterResearch looked at the methods search marketers use most frequently to determine the amount of money to bid for a keyword and the most detailed level they usually use to look at metrics to quantify the effectiveness of search marketing.

He presented data that showed sophisticates are driving spending on search engine marketing. For example, 66% of sophisticates spent $25,000 or more in the past 12 months and 44% spent more than $100,000. In contrast, 64% of unsophisticates spent less than $25,000 in the past 12 months and 48% spent less that $10,000. This includes per-click fees, agency fees, and tool fees.

Sophisticates are happier with SEM and plan to increase the amount of money they spend on search marketing by greater percentages in the next 12 months. Nevertheless, 69% of all search marketers say they will spend more this year on SEM than they did last year.

According to Scevak, there are some key milestones in on the road from being an unsophisticated to becoming a sophisticated search marketer. The key one is adoption of analytics, which enables marketers to expand both the number of keywords and the use of additional paid listing vendors.

Sophistication increases with experience, although a majority of unsophisticates have been using search engines to market their products or services for two or more years.

Sophisticates are more likely to change bids, select keywords, change ad text, or change landing pages. Unsophisticates are less likely to optimize SEM campaigns regularly.

Sophisticates are more likely to measure the effectiveness of search marketing in immediate online sales and the number of leads for online sales. Unsophisticates are more likely to use metrics like increased web traffic.

Sophisticates bid on more paid listing vendors, increasing the number of clicks they generate. For example, 96% of sophisticates work with Google, 91% with Overture, 44% with, and 39% with LookSmart. In contrast, only 80% of unsophisticates work with Google, 68% with Overture, 21% with, and 21% with LookSmart.

Sophisticates currently bid for more keywords with more than a third bidding for more than 1,000 keywords. In contrast, only 14% of unsophisticates bid for more than 1,000 keywords.

Scevak said, “Retailers are the most likely to bid and measure intelligently.” According to JupiterResearch, the professional services industry has the lowest sophistication of bidding and the health care industry has the lowest sophistication of measurement.

Scevak concluded, “Marketers must achieve sophistication in bid strategy and measurement to survive.”

Greg Jarboe is the president and co-founder of SEO-PR, which has formed a strategic partnership with PR Web to provide search engine promotion services through a network of more than 40 search engine marketing firms.

Want to discuss or comment on this story? Join the Three out of Four Search Marketers ‘Unsophisticated’ discussion in the Search Engine Watch forums.

Search Headlines

NOTE: Article links often change. In case of a bad link, use the publication’s search facility, which most have, and search for the headline.

Browser Feature Could Make Scams Easier
ABC News Feb 8 2005 1:36PM GMT
EBay vs. Google Feb 8 2005 1:29PM GMT
Study: K Study: Keyword Prices Get Cheaper After Holidays Feb 8 2005 1:26PM GMT
Yahoo Seeks Spotlight in Hollywood
Los Angeles Times Feb 8 2005 1:24PM GMT
It’s Official: Ask Jeeves Acquires Bloglines
Search Engine Watch Feb 8 2005 1:18PM GMT
Google finds its map service
CNET Feb 8 2005 1:13PM GMT
A New Direction at Google
New York Times Feb 7 2005 7:30PM GMT
The Best Internet Innovation In Years
Forbes Feb 7 2005 7:24PM GMT
Yahoo expands mobile services
Netimperative Feb 7 2005 7:23PM GMT
Microsoft Notebook: MSN Search will bring in dollars even if it’s not
Seattle Post-Intelligencer Feb 7 2005 7:20PM GMT
Gmail gearing up for full launch?
CNET Feb 7 2005 7:13PM GMT
Discomfort over Google site’s hate forums
International Herald Tribune Feb 7 2005 7:12PM GMT
Google May Appeal Trademark Decision
AP Feb 7 2005 7:11PM GMT
Nonconverting Keywords and the Search Continuum, Part 1
ClickZ Today Feb 7 2005 7:04PM GMT
Outlook 2005: Search Continues to Click for Advertisers Feb 7 2005 7:02PM GMT

Related reading

top skills PPC paid search SEM 2019
google search algorithm updates 2018
google ads conversion rates by industry
search industry news trends 2018