How Yahoo Funds Spyware out now by spyware researcher/activist Ben Edelman looks at how Yahoo ads run in plenty
of places beyond Yahoo, including syndication partners he says make use of spyware or adware. It raises again the question of why the major search engines are dragging their
feet on letting people pick-and-choose where their ads will run?
Edelman’s written similarly of Google before and provides links to those reports in this latest one. However, he feels he encounters Yahoo ads more in spyware-infected PCs
than those from other ad networks. He looks closely at Yahoo ads being distributed through Claria, eXact Advertising and Direct Revenue. He also takes aim that Yahoo should be
doing better disclosure of such deals to its advertisers.
Ultimately, if Yahoo can’t do better policing, he says advertisers should be able to pick-and-choose where they appear. I agree. So do most advertisers I talk with. I just
surveyed a room of them at our SES San Jose show last month, and virtually everyone agreed they should be able to choose exactly where they appear.
As a reminder, among the majors, only Google currently offers site exclusion — but only for
its contextual ads. See our past post, New Google AdWords Site Targeting Allows Advertisers To Pick & Choose,
for more info. You still can’t exclude more than 25 sites. However,
site targeting is an opposite feature where you can pick-and-choose exactly the sites you
want, rather than just excluding some.
I’m honestly amazed — actually appalled — that the majors haven’t done more to give advertisers choice here. Let’s just recap a few reasons why:
- It would help eliminate click fraud – BlowSearch Offers Source Exclusion; When Will The Majors Do The
Same? on the blog from March explains how BlowSearch decided to allow source/site exclusion — and Mirago did the same way back in 2003. Is there a site you think is
generating fraudulent clicks? Site exclusion would allow you to get off that site. Moreover, if enough advertisers opt-out of a site, you’re building a database of sites you
might want to blacklist.
- It would prevent embarrassment – That’s what happened to Kraft, when it found its contextual ads
running in Google showing up on a pro-white web site. As mentioned, Google’s site exclusion solves this — but only for the contextual side of the house. Search targeted ads
still lack exclusion.
- It might prevent legal liabilities: As Edelman’s report points out, there might be some legal issues with advertisers who inadvertently support spyware. Legal
issues also came up over Ask Jeeves putting ads on a BitTorrent search engine
The most important reason is that it’s the right thing to do. I’ve talked for years about how search advertising is so rudimentary, as if you wanted to buy a TV ad to run
in association with ER on NBC but are instead told you have to have your ad run with every program, throughout the day.
Let people pick and choose. It’s not only right — it’s overdue to be offered as this industry matures.
Want to discuss? Please visit our Search Engine Watch Forums!
Related reading
Meeker’s Report on the state of advertising and ad trends to watch out for
Mary Meeker’s Internet Trends Report 2017, one of the most-anticipated annual events in the world of digital, was released a few weeks ... read more
3 ways to scale your SEM efforts when you are hitting a wall
It happens to every AdWords practitioner at some point. We launch our campaigns, split out exact match and broad match, mine for queries, work on expansions, test different initiatives, run betas, etc. – and then we hit a wall. Here are a few strategies to break through the SEM wall and grow your account in an effective yet efficient manner.
Three strategies for cracking the B2B code on Facebook
Many tend to assume that B2B marketing on Facebook doesn’t make sense or would not be effective. These assumptions, however, are quite inaccurate – and with the right strategies and targeting in place, Facebook can indeed be an effective B2B platform.
A visual guide to Pinterest advertising
Pinterest has slowly been building itself up as an advertising alternative to Google and Facebook over the past 12 months. As such, it seems timely to take a step back and assess what options are open to marketers, and what you need to know before getting started with Pinterest advertising.
