NBCi Down, Probably Out

The future of the NBCi site as a search resource is now very much in doubt, given the decision by US television network NBC -- which is NBCi's largest shareholder -- to close its spinoff company.

"It's very much a developing situation," said NBC spokesperson Rebecca Tompkins. "What we're doing over the next few months is going through all of NBCi's properties and deciding what we keep, what we sell and what we liquidate."

NBCi was supposed to be NBC's way of winning the portal wars. Instead, the site has lost money, and NBC has decided to cut its losses. NBC's announcement on April 9 echoes a similar move by Disney, which essentially shutdown its money-losing Go.com portal earlier this year.

Just a month after the Disney announcement, Go's homegrown web directory and crawler-based results were gone. No buyer for these search assets had been found, and Go switched over to using pure paid listings provided by GoTo.com. The demise of NBCi's search resources will probably take longer, though perhaps NBC will be luckier in finding a buyer for some of them.

NBCi has four major search features. The NBCi Directory is an editor-compiled guide to the web, similar to those run by Yahoo and LookSmart. This is supplemented by NBCi's LiveDirectory, a system that allows site owners to instantly add their sites to NBCi. On top of these listings, NBCi runs a clickthrough tracking system called GlobalBrain that was acquired in July 1999. Finally, the company acquired the Flyswat search companion in April 2000.

What might buyers want? Go couldn't sell its directory listings for the price it wanted, so NBCi's success in offloading its own directory seems unlikely. The GlobalBrain technology, however, could be used by any search service looking to refine its results. As for Flyswat, the tool can be useful, but it has proven difficult for makers of similar tools to earn money from them. That could make any sale more difficult.

Of course, it is possible that NBCi might continue to maintain these search resources. Possible, but this doesn't seem likely. That because it would be far cheaper and probably more lucrative to follow Disney's lead and switch over to a pure paid listings model, either with a deal through GoTo or perhaps rising contender FindWhat.com.

As with Go, this would be a sad move in that another unique search resource would be lost. However, there would still remain three major directories of the web available to searchers: Yahoo, LookSmart and the Open Directory.

When might changes happen? Probably not until summer, when shareholder agreement over NBC's merger proposal may be obtained.

"Until the day the deal closes, NBCi will look as NBCi looks and will function the same," Tompkins said. "We're anticipating that at some point this summer, there will be shareholder approval."

Understand that NBCi is a separate company that runs the NBCi.com web site. NBC has a big stake in NBCi -- a 38.6 percent share -- but since it does not hold a majority of all shares, it cannot force NBCi to do anything without the support of other shareholders. NBC is proposing that it will acquire all of NBCi's assets, and to gain support of other shareholders, it's offering to buy their shares for US $2.19. That's well above the $1.50 NBCi shares were trading at when the announcement was made.

Of course, there's nothing to prevent NBCi's own management from taking actions to close the company before approval of the merger is obtained. Given this, they've already fired about half the company's 300 workers, and more are planned to be cut. Presumably, NBCi could decide it makes sense to close its directory services sooner, rather than later, and release staff involved with that production. NBC didn't know how many people involved with search had been released already, if any.

One question you might have is why NBC is even bothering trying to acquire NBCi, especially by paying a premium for its shares. Why not let the company just die on its own?

"For NBC, the reason we are doing this is because it allows us to concentrate our Internet strategies on things that make sense to us," Tompkins said.

OK, but surely NBC could do that by just walking away from NBCi entirely. Nothing I've read suggests that NBC was being forced to put more money into NBCi, nor that it was liable for its debts. The one key thing that stands out is the fact that NBCi is entitled to about $400 million in television advertising on NBC. Perhaps that's an asset that could have been passed on to any buyer of NBCi. If so, it may make sense for NBC to acquire and close NBCi if only to remove this liability, especially since the cost of acquiring the outstanding shares is estimated at $138 million -- well under the cost of the advertising NBC owes NBCi.



Short Life, Long Death of NBCi
Wired, April 12, 2001

Review of how NBC gained then lost a portal.

NBCi: The Proud Peacock's Folly
Forbes, April 10, 2001

More details on NBCi's losses.

NBC Pulls Plug on Online Media Venture, NBCi
InternetNews.com, April 9, 2001

More details on the merger and closure announcement.

Go.com Becomes GoTo
SearchEngineWatch.com, March 15, 2001

More details on the closure of Go.