Is It Really Personalized Search?
Both search and social networking are hot! But don't assume that new sites offering both types of services necessarily provide something else that's hot -- search personalization.
Both search and social networking are hot! But don't assume that new sites offering both types of services necessarily provide something else that's hot -- search personalization.
Search is hot — and even hotter is the idea of search personalization. This is where by knowing more about you, a search engine may potentially provide better results because it understands your preferences.
To date, the only released service I know of that’s actually actively doing serious search personalization is Eurekster, which I wrote about back in January. It’s a social networking service that lets who you know influence what you see in search results.
Social networking services are also hot. Now do the math:
social network
X
search
X
search personalization
=
super hot!
That equation means you can expect to hear more about social networking services combined with search. But be wary — this doesn’t mean that true search personalization is offered.
Here are two recent examples: SocialGrid.com and Tickle. Both are social networks. Both have some search features. But neither does anything like Eurekster is doing. Search personalization is not a reality with them.
From this InternetNews.com write-up, SocialGrid.com apparently will create a web page for you that describes your interests and background. Then, it will let you use Google to search against just these pages to find a match. No personalization or refinement of Google results appears to be happening.
Despite the motto of “Transforming Google into a Free Dating Service and Social Network,” it doesn’t appear that Google is actively involved in SocialGrid. Rather, the company may be using the Google API or simply providing a custom form-based interface into Google.
Over at Tickle, a Reuters report suggests that Tickle has personalized search results, thanks to a partnership with Ask Jeeves. In reality, Tickle confirmed for me that a search lets you hit two entirely different databases:
Expect to hear about a string of what I’d dub “social search” or “personalized search” sites spring up in the coming months, especially in the wake of Google’s IPO plans. Everyone will want on the search bandwagon.
Such services may be perfectly fine for what they provide, so certainly do check out places like SocialGrid and Tickle. Just be wary that many of these new sites you will be hearing about may not actually be dishing up personalized search results.
Heck, not even Google’s own Orkut social network service is doing that, yet!
NOTE: Article links often change. In case of a bad link, use the publication’s search facility, which most have, and search for the headline.