Judge to Order Google to Give Up Some Data from the Associated Press covers the news that Google will be required to hand over some information requested by the US Department Of Justice. The DOJ has now asked for a much smaller set of data than it originally sought. It wants 50,000 URLs selected randomly from the Google index and 5,000 random search requests.
Geez, if that's all you need, guess it's confirmed you went overkill on the first request, eh? And what a nice spend of taxpayers money to contest this. I can think of better ways to get 5,000 random URLs out of the Google index and 5,000 search requests from other sources.
The judge in the case has said he intends to have some data, though what exactly remains to be determined. A final ruling will come "very soon" or "very quickly," the judge said, according to other accounts below:
Judge indicates Google must turn over some data, San Jose Mercury News,
covering how Google conceded the new request is less burdensome on it plus
more on the judge's concern that he wants to ensure no private data is
- Judge to help feds against Google, News.com, covering Google's warning that it "could face hundreds of university professors [saying] 'I've got a study I'd like you to conduct'."
For background on the case, see these past articles from us:
Administration Demands Search Data; Google Says No; AOL, MSN & Yahoo Said Yes
Documents & Summary Of United States Versus Google Over Search Data
- The Day
After: Points In The Search Trust Sweepstakes
Groups, Goverment Officials Comment on Privacy and Web Search
Larry Page Comments on Privacy Matters
- MSN Search
Blogs On DOJ Request
- A Brief
Look at Danny's Appearance on Nightline
- Full Text
Reports from the Congressional Research Service on Internet Privacy, Net
Technology, and Protecting Children from "Unsuitable Material"
Your Search Privacy: A Flowchart To Tracks You Leave Behind
Searches Versus Personally Identifiable Searches
- Google Not
Installing Third Party Cookies -- It's Firefox Prefetching
- New Poll
Finds Web Users Want Google to Keep Data Private; Full Text Access to Report
Search Champs Talk to MSN VP about Data Turned Over to Feds
- Search Data
Request Has Searchers Pondering Their Next Query
Senator Patrick Leahy Asks Attorney General for More Info On Web Search
- Google Has
Right to Log the Text of Messages Sent Using their Send to SMS Feature
- How The US
Department Of Justice May Analyze Search Data & Freedom Of Information Act
Request For Disclosure
Search Engines Log IP Addresses & Cookies -- And Why Care?
Privacy Bill Introduced, Not Well Thought Out
Suspect Entwistle's Desktop Search Query to be Used in Court Case
- 60% Oppose
Search Engines Storing Search Behaviors
of Justice Rejects Google's Claims of Privacy Threat
Filings Against DOJ Request -- Including Declaration From Matt Cutts
- Department of Justice Rejects Google's Claims of Privacy Threat
Postscript: Judge will require Google to turn over some documents from USA Today quotes the US DOJ attorney saying of the much pared down request:
"We could perform the study. The study would be substantially improved if we had the Google data."
In my some of my articles on this mess, I've noted one of the frightening things about the US government's original request was how ignorant it seemed to be of the way search engines operate. It had all the feel of "give us data," not "give us what we need." Now we're told that 5,000 random queries will "substantially" improve a study where other search engines were forced to hand over what seems to be millions of queries? Drop in the bucket, anyone? And more important, it again illustrates how far-reaching -- for no good reason -- the original request was.
Meet Your Favorite Search Engine Watch Contributors
Many of SEW's leading expert contributors will be at ClickZ Live, the new online and digital marketing event kicking off in New York (March 31-April 3). Hear from the likes of: Thom Craver, Josh Braaten, Lisa Barone, Simon Heseltine, Josh McCoy, Lisa Raehsler, Greg Jarboe, Dan Cristo, Joseph Kerschbaum, John Gagnon, Eric Enge and more!